Saturday, April 12, 2008

Reckless Dhoni

A wonderful partnership has been built, the fielding team are weary and on the backfoot, India are 17 runs short of the SA total, the new ball is due in 3 overs, and there is only the tail to follow. Watch for the shot the Indian captain plays:


The best bad wicket batsman I have seen:


Labels: , , ,

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Yet another Batting Collapse

Another golden opportunity lost due to an inept batting display. This would be the story of India's loss yesterday. Ofcourse this was what many would have expected from the young batting line. However what nobody expected was the bowling to be so good and the Australian batting to be so fragile. Reducing Australia to modest totals in two consecutive games is no mean feat, and all credit to the Indian bowlers.

The batsman should really be kicking themselves for missing out yesterday. All they had to do was apply themselves and a couple of good partnerships would have taken them home. But alas they seemed to be in a hurry to catch a flight and gifted the Australians easy wickets. Yuvraj finally seemed to be able to hit the ball with the bat and he got himself into the perfect position for redeeming himself. But then he played a horrendous shot when all that was needed was singles and then Dhoni's unfortunate run-out triggered a lower-order collapse. The lower didnt think the bonus point was needed either and they perished to mindless swings.

Dhoni's comments after the game really infuriated me. I have always felt he spoke with a level head and common sense, but of late he has been making comments which have been out of order. It seems as though he will back certain players come what may. Anybody who knows a little bit of cricket can tell Yuvraj is struggling on the field. He is more like a statue at mid-off who picks up the ball when it comes to him. He is not bowling in the nets but Dhoni wants to use him as a bowler in the matches at crucial times. His 4th over yesterday cost 12 runs which started a period of good scoring from the Australians who were struggling until then. Then while batting he plays himself in (which was rare) and then gets out to a stupid shot which Dhoni defends saying "the shot was on, but was executed poorly". It is high time Yuvraj sorts out his fitness issues and shows more commitment and desire on the field. Gavaskar has flayed Munaf for his poor display on the field but Yuvraj was no better.

Dhoni's comments on Rohit Sharma and Irfan Pathan were even worse. He blamed Rohit squarely for his run-out when the young kid dived and tried his best to beat the bullet throw from Hayden. The run-out was a result of excellent fielding from Hayden rather than poor running. Blaming young Rohit for that is totally unjustified.

It is acceptable that he defends his decisions on the field but to say
"Sending Irfan up balances the batting order and keep it stable. And Irfan at 8 or 3 doesn't make too much of a difference." What message does that send out to a young all-rounder in the making? And I really believe Irfan at No.7 would be much more valuable than at No.3 when the ball is new and moving a little bit.

Robin Uthappa is another player Dhoni backs to the hilt, and he might be talented too but he shows no common sense and the way he got out yesterday was pathetic. It was his responsibility as a specialist batsman to get the tail to support him and take as much strike as possible. The tail always plays well when they have a batsman at the other side who is willing to guide them. He will need to show a better temperament to go with his talent in order to succeed in the long run.

It is not from the loss but the way a team loses that the character of a team can be seen. This Indian team needs to show a better character to become a successful unit.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Does Dhoni deserve to be in the Test Team?

Mahendra Singh Dhoni fell to Brett Lee for 20, Australia v India, 4th Test, Adelaide, 5th day, January 28, 2008

Mahendra Singh Dhoni fell to Brett Lee for 20, Australia v India, 4th Test, Adelaide, 5th day, January 28, 2008


Before the ODI series begins and MS Dhoni once again impresses one and all with his captaincy and batting, there is one question that needs to be asked - Does Dhoni really deserve to play in the Indian test team or is he in the team because he has been made the ODI captain?

Forget his captaincy and his ODI performances. Just look at him as a test-match wicket-keeper who bats at No.7. He averaged a mere 17 in this series against Australia while both Harbhajan and Kumble who bat below him managed better averages. Infact even India's No.11 Ishant Sharma averaged 21.50 in the series. So the fact is that India needs more runs from its No.7 batsman. Dhoni's failures have been covered up by the performance of the tail in this series. But it is something which needs to be addressed.

Gujarat's Parthiv Patel raises his bat on reaching his fifty, Gujarat v Madhya Pradesh, Ranji Trophy Plate League, 1st semi-final, 3rd day, Karnail Singh Stadium, Delhi, December 27, 2007
What is most astonishing is the bench strength that India has on the wicket keeping front. Ofcourse there is Dinesh Karthick who was opening the innings until sometime back. But the more interesting option is Parthiv Patel. He burst on to the International scene as a kid and was hailed as a wonderful talent. His batting was solid but his keeping which was brilliant at the start went bad and he was dropped. Now Parthiv is playing at No.3 for Gujarat and the India A teams and has made heaps of runs last season. His keeping is back to what it was at the beginning of his career and everybody is gushing about how his batting has come of age. How much longer are the selectors going to ignore him? It is only fair that he is given a chance when Dhoni is failing in the test arena.

India's next test series is against the proteas at home. So Dhoni might well play and make some runs on home pitches. It is on away pitches and against quality bowling that the question arises. India might well have to consider having two different keepers and two different captains for the two forms of the game.


Labels: , ,